Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Caught My Eye: Hiring and LinkedIn

In his personal branding blog for Forbes magazine online, Dan Schwabel posits that LinkedIn will replace job boards like the Monster Board.

After all, LinkedIn already provides much of the same information about a candidate as a resume (or CV in Montreal).

Plus a new feature on LinkedIn lets applicants apply for jobs, thus opening their LinkedIn profile to prospective employers.

Although I'm no expert on recruiting, I'm not 100 percent sure about either prediction.

  • As far as LinkedIn replacing job boards--I can see it providing stiff competition to general purpose job boards like the Monster Board and Workopolis. But as far as replacing special purpose job boards, like those of professional associations, I'm not as sure. Because such boards provide a screening function (for example, only people interested in training would look at the CSTD job board), they still serve a useful purpose.
  • As far as the death of the resume goes, I'm not sure about that either. Although LinkedIn profiles provide a lot of information about people (and increasingly provide more), the resume has room for more information. In fact, the curriculum vitae (CV), which is a complete record of all activities and is not limited to 2 pages, may make a comeback precisely because it provides more detailed information.


What are your thoughts? I welcome your comments below.

Check out the original blog entry at: http://blogs.forbes.com/danschawbel/2011/06/01/linkedin-is-about-to-put-job-boards-and-resumes-out-of-business/

2 comments:

  1. Saul,

    I also have my reservations about both predictions.

    As far as LinkedIn replacing job boards, this is not LinkedIn's main objective. I would agree that yes, it does provide stiff competition to the Monsters and Workopolis boards, but that at the same time, the way in which LinkedIn is structured is not set up optimally to be a job board.

    I would add that the best way to post a job on LinkedIn is to do so in the highly specialised groups under the jobs posting tab. That strategy has worked well for our company.

    As for Linkedin replacing the resume, I'd argue that most of my 700+ contacts do not have a profile that is detailed enough to give me an indication of their skills, capabilities and accomplishments, something which a well built resume should do. Basically, for the majority of LinkedIn participants, you'll see a company, a title and years worked at the company, more often then not without a description of the position in the space provided. For many, you only see their current position. I'm not suggesting that all resumes are stellar, but I suspect that people put more time into crafting their resume than in filling in their LinkedIn profile.

    Here is another reference to an article from 99%, which is the Behance’s research arm and think tank. on how the resume is dead and the bio is king (http://the99percent.com/tips/7025/The-Resume-Is-Dead-The-Bio-Is-King). I'd say a bio is a good way to get them to notice you, but without a solid resume to back it up, you aren't going to get very far, not with discerning people.

    I will add that LinkedIn sees to be a dream-come-true for head hunters who now have access to a massive international talent pool. And for those who have taken the time to organise their LinkedIn profile accurately and professionally (like apparently I have), the calls from headhunters can be quite frequent.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice to know that someone shares my concerns :)

    ReplyDelete