Monday, December 19, 2011

Should You Go to Work When You Are Sick?

No.  

Doing so saps overall productivity, according to a study by Gary Johns at Concordia University, and reported by Karen Seidman in the Montreal Gazette (http://www.montrealgazette.com/health/Staying+home+help+productivity+Concordia+study/5729045/story.html). 

Presenteeism (the technical term for going to work while ill) affects productivity while the worker is sick and prolongs the illness.  Worse, the sick worker probably infects other workers and service recipients (think of what happens if a sick nurse goes to work or a sick server goes to work).

So if you’re a manager, encourage your sick workers to stay home and get better.  If you’re concerned about productivity--note that research suggests that this sensible advice is also the more productive course of action.  

Friday, December 16, 2011

"Constructive" Criticism?

In a blog in the HRB Blog Network, Tony Schwartz writes
"Here's a question guaranteed to make your stomach lurch: "Would you mind if I gave you some feedback?"
What that actually means is "Would you mind if I gave you some negative feedback, wrapped in the guise of constructive criticism, whether you want it or not?"
Schwartz notes that the problem with feedback is that it leaves people feeling judged; that’s why it immediately raises fears.  

However, he acknowledges:
“The conundrum is that feedback is necessary. It's the primary means by which we learn and grow. So what's the best way to deliver it in a way that it provides the greatest value — meaning the recipient truly absorbs and acts on it?”
The rest of the column explores some behaviors that  people use when they give criticism, and affects the manner in which the recipient takes that criticism.  Schwartz also offers some suggestions for moderating those behaviors so that the recipient is more likely to accept the criticism.  

Wednesday, December 14, 2011

Could your name be a liability when searching for a job?

In What’s in a name? A job, maybe, published on the Economy Lab blog of the Globe and Mail, Tavia Grant reports on a recent study by University of Toronto researchers Philip Oreopoulos and Diane Dechief that tracked the number of callbacks received from different job candidates.  Oreopoulos and Dechief found that
“applications submitted by people with English-sounding names are 47 per cent more likely to receive callbacks than those with Indian or Chinese ones in Toronto, 39 per cent more likely in Montreal, and 20 per cent more likely in Vancouver.”
In addition:
“The researchers found that people with Greek, Chinese and Indian names are less likely to hear back from employers. ‘Even for applicants with Canadian education and Canadian experience ... the result is concerning that there this a difference that’s generated from a name,’ Mr. Oreopoulos said.”
Researchers asked HR managers why they felt this situation existed; many admitted the possibility of unconscious discrimination.

This unconscious discrimination unfortunately affects the real lives of people.  Studies of immigrants to Canada, for example, have noted a significant and persistent income gap between immigrants and native born Canadians, even when those immigrants have the qualifications for higher-paying work.

What does this mean to hiring managers reading this blog?  Perhaps the next time you review applications, you might  ask yourself:  Am I making sure that all qualified candidates are receiving full consideration? 

Monday, December 12, 2011

Looking for a Leader for Your Organization?

Consider this advice offered by Johns Hopkins University neuroscientist David J. Linden in a recent piece for the New York Times.
“When searching for your organization’s next leader, look for someone with an attenuated dopamine function: someone who is never satisfied with the status quo, someone who wants the feeling of success more than others — but likes it less.”
He describes the
“psychological profile of a compelling leader — think of tech pioneers like Jeff Bezos, Larry Ellison and Steven P. Jobs — is also that of the compulsive risk-taker, someone with a high degree of novelty-seeking behavior.  In short, what we seek in leaders is often the same kind of personality type that is found in addicts, whether they are dependent on gambling, alcohol, sex or drugs.”
Don’t believe it?  He then lists many well-regarded leaders and their addictive habits. 

Learn more about this link between the psychological profile of a compelling leader and compulsive risk-takers at  
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/24/opinion/sunday/24addicts.html?ref=opinion.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Caught My Eye: Resume Don'ts

As noted in an earlier post, some people think the resume is history because people use LinkedIn instead but I expressed reservations about that, as did a commenter.

If for no other reason than as a backup, people should still prepare their resumes (called CVs in Quebec).

I found a great summary of issues to avoid when doing so at:
http://www.businessinsider.com/worst-resume-blunders-2011-5#

For those not in the mood to click on the link, here is my paraphrasing of things not to do:

(Except for the tip on the color of paper not to use, most of these tips apply as much to online resumes and LinkedIn profiles as they do to printed resumes.)
  1. Make copyediting errors (misspellings, grammatical errors, and misuse of punctuation (stay away from colons--they're a trap)). That said, errors inadvertently slip through, even among experts.  For example, I once heard an editing manager announce that she wouldn't hire anyone who made a single error in their resume.  I guess she wouldn't have hired herself--she inadvertently misspelled her own name.)
  2. Include photos.  (A no-no.)
  3. Print the resume on paper other than white, cream or very light gray.  The article says colored paper, but I saw a study once (so many years ago, I can't remember where), that found that hese three colors were acceptable (though one--and I can't remember which--was preferred to the others.  
  4. Provide TMI--too much information.
  5. Name references.  The people named might not be the right people to answers the prospective employers' questions.
  6. Saying "references available upon request." (I've been guilty of this.)  Of course they are--so no need to say it.  
  7. "Us[e] buzzwords like results-oriented, team-player, and motivated."  The expressions are so over-used, they're vapid.  Besides, who would say on their application that they're anything less than a good performer who gets along well with others? 
  8. Name your hobbies.  That's individually pursued hobbies, unless they can provide insights into skills and abilities that are relevant to the job . For example, 'committed Gleek' doesn't really say much about one's skills and abilities, but 'competitive rower' indicates that the applicant must take initiative, practices regularly, and works with teams.  
  9. Use long sentences and long paragraphs.  The article says they're a pain to read; but that assumes that hiring managers would even go to that inconvenience.  
  10. "Us[e] an unprofessional e-mail address" like sweetiepie55@service.com 
  11. Forget your name, address, phone number, and e-mail address.  If they can't reach you, they can't hire you.
  12. "Address [the resume] to the wrong company."  That's like calling out someone else's name at an intimate moment.  Everyone likes to feel special.  



Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Caught My Eye: Can Harmony Hurt Team Performance?

In the academic course, Administration of Educational Technology Units, that I teach at Concordia and the Technical Communication Manager certificate program that I teach for the Society for Technical Communication, I include an exercise on hiring workers.

One of the scenarios in the exercise focuses on a situation in which a manager has the opportunity to bring a brash 25-year-old man into a harmonious department of primarily comprised of middle-aged women. In the scenario, most of the workers express concern that the young man won’t fit in but the person who would work most closely with the young man says that she’s comfortable working with him.

Most people respond that the manager should not hire him because the candidate could disrupt the harmony of the group.

But the point of the exercise is that the harmony might not be a “healthy” harmony, it could be group-think, because the managers of the department have tended to hire clones of the workers.

“Can Harmony Hurt Team Performance?” by Mark de Rond, Adrian Moorhouse, and Matt Rogan and recently posted on The Conversation blog of the Harvard Business Review online specifically explores this type of situation.

The authors suggest that harmony can hurt team performance when:

  • “Competition is stifled for the sake of promoting interpsonal harmony,” adding that that competition does not disappear, it merely finds another outlet, usually in the form of office gossip.
  • True “harmony is far more likely to be the consequence, and not the cause, of team performance.” Better than “harmony” is a situation in which workers feel they can safely say what they feel without hurting the overall dynamic of the team, an.
  • “What can feel dysfunctional need not be dysfunctional,” suggesting that workers in the midst of a project might not be in the best position to assess the dynamics of the team working on it.


Check out the entire piece at:

http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2011/06/can_harmony_hurt_team_performa.html?cm_sp=blog_flyout-_-cs-_-can_harmony_hurt_team_performa.

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Caught My Eye: Hiring and LinkedIn

In his personal branding blog for Forbes magazine online, Dan Schwabel posits that LinkedIn will replace job boards like the Monster Board.

After all, LinkedIn already provides much of the same information about a candidate as a resume (or CV in Montreal).

Plus a new feature on LinkedIn lets applicants apply for jobs, thus opening their LinkedIn profile to prospective employers.

Although I'm no expert on recruiting, I'm not 100 percent sure about either prediction.

  • As far as LinkedIn replacing job boards--I can see it providing stiff competition to general purpose job boards like the Monster Board and Workopolis. But as far as replacing special purpose job boards, like those of professional associations, I'm not as sure. Because such boards provide a screening function (for example, only people interested in training would look at the CSTD job board), they still serve a useful purpose.
  • As far as the death of the resume goes, I'm not sure about that either. Although LinkedIn profiles provide a lot of information about people (and increasingly provide more), the resume has room for more information. In fact, the curriculum vitae (CV), which is a complete record of all activities and is not limited to 2 pages, may make a comeback precisely because it provides more detailed information.


What are your thoughts? I welcome your comments below.

Check out the original blog entry at: http://blogs.forbes.com/danschawbel/2011/06/01/linkedin-is-about-to-put-job-boards-and-resumes-out-of-business/

Friday, June 3, 2011

What? Money in Documentation?

A recent article in the business pages of the Montreal Gazette describes a successful local business that sells templates for standard business documents like policies, procedures, accounting reports, and legal documents.

Among the many issues making this application interesting is that the documents are created to work across companies, industries, and countries, and in many different languages. The challenge to designers is finding what’s common in all of that diversity.

This success story poses some challenges to professional communicators, however. The availability of templates like these could affect work opportunities for policies and procedures writers. Clip illustrations have had a huge impact on the opportunities available to illustrators, so it is likely that the availability of templates for standard operating documents has affected work opportunities for technical communicators.

Learn more about this success story at http://www.montrealgazette.com/business/Documentation+made+easy/4825562/story.html.

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

The Failure Rate of New Hires

During the Technical Communication Manager certificate that I taught the weekend of May 14 at the Society for Technical Communication Annual Summit, I mentioned that about half of all new hires don't work out.

This morning, I saw some research from Human Capital Media, the publisher of Talent Management and CLO Magazines, which found that the percentage of new hires that don't work out is 46 percent. The study also found that the majority of the new hires did not work out for attitudinal reasons, rather than skills reasons.

If you would like to see a summary of the study, visit
http://www.leadershipiq.com/hiring-for-attitude-to-skyrocket-your-success-rate/?code=tm

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

Textbooks to Train Your Staff

Someone on the STC Management List asked about the best book to train new technical writers. I had some thoughts and posted them there, but thought I should also share them here.

Managers need to prepare workers through several stages of development as technical writers. Each one demands different books.

Preparation: Before workers are really ready to write an entire manual, they need to master the basic "components" of this writing and hone their professional writing style (which drastically differs from the academic and business-ese most are used to) to present information people will use.

So workers first need to learn how to write the "building blocks" of larger works, such as definitions, procedures, and procedures. Two types of books are useful at this phase:

  • Books that explain how to write these building blocks. Any of the "big" textbooks on the field, such as Lay (Schuster) et al, Pfeiffer, Anderson, or Markel.
  • These are generalist books, but I've tried throwing new writers right into an entire manual and found that their lack of grasp of basics gets in the way of their handling more complex task.

  • At least one grammar book. Strunk & White's Elements of Style continues to be a best-seller for a reason.

Initiation: after you're convinced they have the basics down, prepare workers to write a complete manual, help system or similar full-size project. At that point, you probably want two types of books:

  • A primer on writing documentation. Price's 1985 book on writing a computer manual is probably THE classic. For the online era, his 2002 book with his wife Lisa is equally superb.
  • A primer on the "work" of technical communication, such as Techniques for Technical Communicators (disclaimer--I co-edited it; I also recognize that it's old, but a lot of people have trained with it)

Expansion: To introduce more complex assignments and broaden their skills, such as writing in particular genres, and mastering particular parts of the process, such as visual communication, you'll need a different set of books.

  • About genres--for writing instructional materials, Training Design Basics (disclosure--this is my book) or one of Bill Horton's books on writing instructions, or Jane Bozarth's More than Bullet Points

  • For particular aspects of communication--Slide-Ology (for writing Powerpoint slides), Bill Horton's book on illustrating computer documentation or Robin Williams' book on design for nondesigners, one of the many usability texts out there (Carol Barnum just published a new edition of her book--my students who have self-taught themselves usability found it very helpful), Ann Rockley's primer on content management, and Joann Hackos' books on management (I still prefer her 1994 edition, but the 2007 edition is more current)

This is just a starter list. Comments about other books would be welcome. I'll update the post with the feedback I receive.

Monday, February 21, 2011

HR Assurance of Learning

The U.S-based Society for Human Resource Management has launched its Assurance of Learning, which it labels as "the new universal benchmark for undergraduate level HR students."

Essentially, the Assurance of Learning is an exam for students graduating from Human Resources (HR) programs.  Students who pass the exam receive a certificate of learning that informs:
hiring managers that they have sufficient knowledge to enter the workforce.
This takes the general HR certification programs to a new level.  As other professions, like Training (Human Resource Development), and technical communication launch and develop their certification programs, the path of the broader HR profession from a group of isolated certifications to widespread recognition of the credential provides a model to observe.

Friday, February 18, 2011

Does Every Good Job Require a Four-Year Degree?

"Bunk," claims Mike Rowe, the star of the U.S. cable TV show Dirty Jobs (who holds a bachelor's degree), according to Mike Rowe, host of TV's 'Dirty Jobs,' in a recent article by Lorraine Mirabella in the Baltimore Sun, the news paper of Mike's and my hometown (no, I don't know him).

In his show, Rowe performs a different "dirty" job each week, which are predominantly skilled jobs that do not require a bachelor's degree.

The experienced has transformed him.  According to the article, Rowe commented that:
"When you portray people doing work that's dirty or difficult or dangerous, but you don't show them being miserable and completely wrapped in drudgery, you send an interesting message to millions of people" 
In response, he's made his mission to advocate for skilled labor.  In doing so, Rowe has launched the website,  MikeRoweWorks.com, "to highlight the decline in the trades and boost enrollment in trade schools."

Rowe isn't the only one who feels this way.  A number of recent articles and books, like Anya Kamenetz's DIY U, raise the question.

But few are doing anything aimed at potential skilled laborers as Rowe.

Check out the article at http://www.baltimoresun.com/business/bs-bz-mike-rowe-jobs-20110118,0,7205510.story.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Go Northward My Friend

The relative strength of the Canadian job market and the reasonably high standard of living here has attracted not only Target stores (though I still have to wait at least 2 years for the first store opening), but also immigrants in search of a better life and opportunity.

As an immigrant to Canada, this issue resonates on a personal level with me.

Canada Lures Immigrants
In Defying Trend, Canada Lures More Migrants, reporter Jason DeParle, notes that, while immigration has become a prickly topic in many countries like the Australia, UK, US, and many European Union members, immigration successfully continues in Canada with little of the political fallout experienced by those other countries.

In fact, DeParle notes that some Canadian provinces are so eager to attract immigrants that they have successfully worked withCanadian immigration officials to develop policies that would attract immigrants to those parts of the country.  In many instances, immigrants fill huge gaps in the workforce and are the primary source of population growth.

Read the article at  http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/13/world/americas/13immig.html?ref=homepage&src=me&pagewanted=all.

If You're Thinking of Immigrating
If it inspires you to immigrate to Canada, you might be interested in the practical employment advice offered to prospective immigrants by Sumedh Nene, a recent immigrant to Canada from India, a two-part article published in the Indus, the newsletter of the India chapter of the Society for Technical Communication.

In Canada Calling (http://indus.stc-india.org/2010/10/canada-calling/), Nene explains how the labyrinth of the Canadian immigration process, and provides practical information about living in the Toronto Metropolitan area.  Although Toronto differs from other metro areas, much of the experience is similar in most other metro areas  in the country.

In  The  Hidden Job Market of Canada (http://indus.stc-india.org/2010/08/want-to-work-in-canada-read-this-first/), Nene provides helpful, practical advice for navigating the job search process--from tips on preparing a resume (called a CV in parts of Canada, not to be confused with a CV in other countries), as well as the etiquette of the job interview process.

Even though Nene reports primarily contrasts the Canadian system with the Indian one, the insights should be useful to all potential and current immigrants to Canada.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Try It, Maybe Buy It

Employment Trends

The next several of posts address issues in employment.  The first two address job market issues, subsequent posts address skills .

Try It, Maybe Buy It
Reporting on what might seem obvious to many who follow the job market, New York Times reporter Motoko Rich reports that companies increasingly favor hiring contingent (temporary) workers in Weighing Costs, Companies Favor Temporary Help.

For example, Rich reports that:
This year, 26.2 percent of all jobs added by private sector employers were temporary positions. 
Then puts this in perspective of hiring trends in previous recessions:
In the comparable period after the recession of the early 1990s, only 10.9 percent of the private sector jobs added were temporary, and after the downturn earlier this decade, just 7.1 percent were temporary.
Although these figures come from the U.S. labor market, they reflect trends in the Canadian market, too.

Rich cites a well-known economist, when writing that:
Temporary employees still make up a small fraction of total employees, but that segment has been rising steeply over the past year. “It hints at a structural change,” said Allen L. Sinai, chief global economist at the consulting firm Decision Economics. Temp workers “are becoming an ever more important part of what is going on,” he said.
From my personal perspective, this is the realization of a trend predicted back in the early 1990s, when futurists predicted that work would be organized around small, flexible teams that come together for a project, then disband and move onto new projects, often with different people and, perhaps, different organizations.

In such an economy, workers are hired for their skills, rather than for their seniority.  In theory this sounds good because it provides everyone with flexibility.  If an employer no longer needs a skill, employers can lay off workers with those skills.  And if workers finds better situations that more effectively (or rewardingly) use their skills, workers can easily transfer among jobs.

The broader implications of such a system have not been fully thought through, much less implemented.

But that's beyond the scope of Rich's article.  It focuses, instead, on the people affected by this hiring trend.   Check out the article at http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/20/business/economy/20temp.html?ref=general&src=me&pagewanted=all

Monday, February 7, 2011

Spending on Training Stuck in Neutral

At the Training Conference today, I presented Ingy Bakir's and my analysis of spending patterns on training between 1982 and 2008. As the title suggests, spending hasn't grown in the past 24 years after adjusting for inflation, although it did during some of the periods of the survey.

To see the original article in Training, visit

http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/nielsen/training_201002/index.php?startid=16#/18

The complete analysis is published in the third quarter 2010 issue of the peer-reviewed journal, Performance Improvement Quaraterly.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Upcoming Presentations During the First Half of 2011

Following are the presentations that I am scheduled to give in the first half of 2011.
Highlighted presentations have a focus on business and management issues.

Slides for most of these presentations are typically available through the Concordia University repository about 10 working days after a presentation. Slides and papers for older presentations are currently available.
Presentation Event Location Date
Spending on Training Stuck in Neutral Training 2011 San Diego, California February 5-6, 2011
An Integrative Review of Literature on Perceptions of Training Held by Clients (with Colleen Bernard) Academy of Human Resource Development Research Conference in the Americas Schaumberg, Illinois February 23-26, 2011
Bridging Research and Practice: An Interim Report on 5 Pilot Projects Academy of Human Resource Development Research Conference in the Americas Schaumberg, Illinois February 23-26, 2011
Certification and the Branding of HRD Academy of Human Resource Development Research Conference in the Americas Schaumberg, Illinois February 23-26, 2011
Research-Validated Practices for Designing Effective e-Learning The User Assistance Conference by WritersUA Long Beach, California March 13, 2011
Eight Design Lessons We Can Learn from Museums Learning Solutions Conference of the e-Learning Guild Orlando, Florida March 23, 2011
Out of Range or Out of Touch: Verifying that the Development Staff Has Up-to-Date Skills Learning Solutions Conference of the e-Learning Guild Orlando, Florida March 24, 2011
Is Informal Learning Right for You? Ten Issues and Technologies to Consider Learning Solutions Conference of the e-Learning Guild Orlando, Florida March 23, 2011
The Incredible Shrinking e-Learning Program Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychologists Annual Conference Chicago, Illinois April 12, 2011
Profession Building: What the Peer-Reviewed Literature Tells Us (with Nancy Coppola) Society for Technical Communication Annual Summit Sacramento, California May 15-18, 2011
Narratives Over Numbers: Why Qualitative Research Is Essential (with Jamie Conklin, George Hayhoe, Hillary Hart, and Menno de Jong) Society for Technical Communication Annual Summit Sacramento, California May 15-18, 2011
Informal Learning and You: 10 Issues and Technologies to Consider American Society for Training and Development International Conference and Exposition Orlando, Florida May 21, 2011
Visions of TechComm 2.0 Metro New York chapter of the Society for Technical Communication New York, New York June 16, 2011

Friday, February 4, 2011

Do You Really Know How to Give a Performance Review?

In Learning Before Reviewing published in CLO Magazine, Ladan Nikravan emphasizes the importance of training managers in the performance review process before they actually perform them.

But Nikravan notes--as is also noted in my academic and certificate courses--that a once-a-year conversation isn't really the best way to ensure that performance issues are addressed.  Year-round conversations are important as well as clear performance metrics, which people can get on their own at any time they want the information.

Check out the article at http://www.clomedia.com/articles/view/4007# .

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

The Difficult Conversation about Performance

Most workers abhor poor performance (at least, the poor performance of their co-workers).  More significantly, so do most managers.

But tackling poor performance requires having difficult conversations about work standards, and many managers prefer to avoid it.

In How to... address poor performance, published in the UK magazine, People Management, author Kate Russell explains why "Avoiding difficult conversations about work standards can demotivate other staff."

Although many have written about the issue of confronting poor performance, what sets this article apart is that it addresses the issue from the perspective of the other employees.

At the least, these other employees might feel that the poor performer is being appraised against an easier set of performance criteria than they are.

At the most, these other employees depend on their poor-performing co-workers to accomplish their jobs, and the failure of the manager to confront the issue prevents these workers from performing at their best.

Russell offers specific suggestions for preparing for the conversation about performance, conducting it and, most importantly, following up with coaching and feedback.

When a worker starts a job, a lack of ongoing coaching and feedback has the potential to reinforce and solidify poor performance.

And if the manager has effectively raised the concern about performance with the poor-performing worker, that workers needs the coaching and feedback to re-align his or her efforts with the manager's.  

Check out the article at: http://www.peoplemanagement.co.uk/pm/articles/2010/11/how-to-address-poor-performance.htm?area=pm.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

Some Random Thoughts on the ROI of Training

It's been an interesting period for demonstrating returns on training programs. The Phillipses sent out a call for cases for the latest volume on demonstrating the Return-on-Investment in training.

Not long before that, CLO Magazine published a press release Organizations Fail to Tie Learning to Business Impact from consulting firm ESI International about its "global survey," which reveals that "more than half of organizations (50.7 percent) do not measure the business impact of their learning programs." (Visit http://clomedia.com/articles/view/3965 to see the entire press release.)

The reasons aren't surprising:
a lack of resources and people qualified to track impact, as well as the need for a better understanding of measurement methodologies. Also, up to half of survey respondents in charge of learning program initiatives still do not believe measurement is a priority or a requirement.
ESI clearly does. And as a third-party provider, they do need to demonstrate that their training programs and services provide value to clients.

But the findings of ESI don't really differ from anyone else's results. In fact,
despite sustained interest in demonstrating a financial benefit to training, researchers repeatedly find that organizations rarely track the impact or return of training. In their 2003 article, Effectiveness of Training in Organizations: A Meta-Analysis of Design and Evaluation Features, researchers Winfred Arthur, Jr. (Texas A&M University), Winston Bennett, Jr, (Air Force Research Laboratory), Pamela S. Edens and Suzanne T. Bell (Texas A&M University) found that fewer than 10 percent of all training programs were evaluated for transfer of behavior or impact.

More recently, in their 2007 meta-analysis of 67 studies, A review and critique of research on training and organizational-level outcomes in Human Resource Management Review (volume 17, pages 251-273), researchers Phyllis Tharenou (University of South Australia), Alan Saks (University of Toronto), and Celia Moore (London Business School) found that "training is positively related to human resource outcomes and organizational performance but is only very weakly related to financial outcomes."

The work of researchers Lynnette Gillis and Allan Bailey, in their study of 12 cases for Human Resources and Skills Development Canada, sheds light on why, even organizations that thought their training had a positive return-on-investment, often could not demonstrate it. In some cases, the programs had no clear business objectives. In other cases, the programs went off-track somewhere between request and implementation.

Although I recognize that demonstrating ROI is a cultural practice in business and that, for some projects, doing so makes a good idea, based on my reading and my own research, I'm reaching the conclusion that, for everyday purposes, we probably need a much different way to demonstrate the value of training programs. The measures definitely need to be practical and easily obtained, as well as credible. Most efforts to demonstrate ROI fall short on at least 1 of these criteria.

But perhaps the focus of assessment needs to shift from assessing the course to assessing the function of training. That won't necessarily be easier; for example, many organizations include training expenses into a number of budget categories other than training, including conferences, professional development, even marketing and general operations. As a result, simply finding all of the funds invested in training is an exercise in forensic accounting.

But maybe individual training programs, in isolation, do not have a complete impact on workers. Maybe it's the combined effect of all of the training that does. Furthermore, the mere process of inventorying out all of the training that an organization has invested in might, on its own, provide many sponsors with compelling data that their investment has indeed paid off.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Upcoming Workshops

Following are the workshops that I am scheduled to teach in the first half of 2011.

Highlighted workshops have a management or business focus.

Workshops
Workshop Event Location Date
Advanced Design for e-Learning Certificate Program Training 2011 San Diego, California February 5-6, 2011
Writing Engaging eLearning Exercises and Test Questions The User Assistance Conference by WritersUA Long Beach, California March 13, 2011
The Incredible Shrinking e-Learning Program Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychologists Annual Conference Chicago, Illinois April 12, 2011
Technical Communication Manager Certificate Program Society for Technical Communication Annual Summit Sacramento, California May 14-15, 2011
Developing the Business Case for a Major Project American Society for Training and Development International Conference and Exposition Orlando, Florida May 21, 2011
Following Form: 13 Real-World Insights for Template-Based Writing Metro New York chapter of the Society for Technical Communication New York, New York June 16, 2011
Additional Half-Day Workshop Metro New York chapter of the Society for Technical Communication New York, New York June 16, 2011
Technical Communication Manager Certificate Program Online Education by the Society for Technical Communication Online TBD

Thursday, January 27, 2011

But Can the Team Be Friends?

Even if the boss manages to find a way to be caring, even close, without being friends, what types of relationships among the staff should the manager nurture?  When You Don’t Want Employees to Agree by Katie Loehrke and published in CLO Magazine, suggests that:
Harmony in the workplace is a good thing, but often conflict is needed to keep a team efficient and innovative.
Loehrke raises the concern that:
Most leaders are happy when a group reaches a consensus, but if a group arrives at a major decision without much discussion and with few variations in thought, consider what’s really going on. Did the team agree because their solution was truly the best option, or could one of these other sets of circumstances have occurred?
In other words, people confuse a seeming consensus because they prefer it to the conflict and delays that might ensue in reaching an actual consensus.

Several situations cause this: people choosing not to state their opinions for fear of disrupting group harmony, for lack of better solutions than the one proposed, or for fear of earning a reputation as a troublemaker.

The result is groupthink; although it creates short-term peace, it can disrupt long-term performance because important issues that team members could have raised never made their way into the discussion.

Loehrke suggests a couple of causes for group think:

  • Intimidation by one or a small group of people, which prevents some people from speaking up for fear of consequences.  The dominator might be the manager but it might also result from team dynamics.  Fixing that dynamic involves exploring how it came to be and how it operates.  
  • Hiring people who think alike because they have similar backgrounds and experiences.  Certainly hiring a more diverse workforce can address some of that, but it's amazing how people from diverse backgrounds can, at the core, think alike.  Hiring diversely also means hiring diverse personality types and opinions.  

Preventing group think also involves effective facilitation techniques for meetings, which can bring diverse opinions to the fore in a non-threatening way.

To learn more, check out the article at http://clomedia.com/articles/view/when-you-don-t-want-employees-to-agree/.

Monday, January 24, 2011

A Guide to Transferable Credentials--and a Certification Decoder--for Trainers

From Training magazine online:
Thinking about certifying as a training and development professional? You certainly have many choices. U.S.-based professionals can choose among the CPLP, CPT, and CTT and those living in Canada have national certifications.
In addition to spelling out those acronyms, this article identifies the certifications available to training and development professionals. But first, it places certification within the broader scope of external credentials, and describes the role of transferable credentials in attesting to the qualifications of training and development professionals.
Check out the entire article at http://tinyurl.com/4z9tdw7

Employment Issues and Keith Olberman's Firing.

I'll start by admitting--although I recognize that Keith Olberman's departure from MSNBC has stirred great passion among his supporters on the left and detractors on the left, as someone who never really got into his show, I don't really care about any of that. 

Rather, I am more interested in the relationship between Olberman and his employer, his motivation to work, his work ethic, and its broader implications for others, starting with my students, many of whom are just starting in their careers. 

An article in the New York Times, Monday, January 24, sheds light on what really happened.  According to the report (which you can find at  http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/24/business/media/24olbermann.html?hp), Olberman had a pattern of enthusiastically starting a job, then becoming disillusioned.  In the process, he would often do something he shouldn't (like threatening to appear on a competitive network without permission) and exacerbate an increasingly fractured relationship with his bosses.  

Reading between the lines, it also sounds like he might have been a bit of a perfectionist and the workload needed to maintain perfectionism in any given job would ultimately get the best of him each time.  As what seems like burnout increased, so did the difficult behavior.  

That's not a recipe for long-term success. 

Some lessons that I'm taking away from this situation: 

For managers:  Watch out for superstar employees who seem to be going way above and beyond to impress.  At some point, they might crash and burn.  

That said, in some cases, the employee might not be "coach-able," that is, open to the constructive feedback that could save them from themselves.  Certainly the star system at networks doesn't help that process; it only feeds the ego.  

For workers:  Watch out for perfectionism and doing a lot of unnecessary additional work.  In the short run, it might impress someone.  But in the long-run, it will burn you out and turn you into a crabby person.  That crabby person will impress people as much as the superstar did--and will be as significant for your reputation as when you were a superstar.  
 

    

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Can Bosses Be Friends?

Even above board relationships in the work place can be tricky. (Yes, I watch too many B-shows and movies.)

The next couple of posts offer some sound advice for navigating this territory from articles I recently read.

Can Bosses Be Friends?
The first, Be the boss, not a friend, published at Fortune/CNNMoney.com, is an excerpt from Linda Hill and Kent Lineback's book, Being the Boss: The 3 Imperatives for Becoming a Great Leader by Linda A. Hill and Kent Lineback and suggests why seeking friendship from workers, or simply trying to be liked, isn't in the best interests of a productive work relationship.

Noting that the relationship between boss and worker "exists to accomplish work," they offer several reasons why seeking friendship with workers is a bad idea. All of the reasons come down to the basic issue: managers are responsible for achieving certain results. If those results are not achieved, managers need to counsel workers, put them on probation, and possibly even lay them off. But that's not easy if the manager and the worker are friends.

They also note that, if managers are friends with their staff, they're likely to be closer friends with some workers than others, only adding to tensions in the workplace.

To be honest, this article reminded me of one of my favorite topics from the old Ricki Lake show, "You used to be my friend, now you're my boss," which explored the transition from friends to manager and worker (albeit in a purposefully combative way).

Hill and Linebeck conclude that:
In a word, the boss–subordinate relationship is another paradox, one of the most profound you will encounter as a boss. It's a paradox because it must be genuinely human and caring—even close.
Check out the article at http://management.fortune.cnn.com/2011/01/18/be-the-boss-not-a-friend/.